At the Portman Clinic he is involved in individual and group therapy for trans people who want a
The Daily Telegraph
In 2002 in response to the European Court ruling in the case of Christine Goodwin v. the UK that she had, among other rights, the right to marry a male person, Hakeem and 5 others wrote to The Daily Telegraph that such a ruling was
“a victory for fantasy over reality and that our concerns were that the problems and conflicts within the trans-sexually conflicted individual may not be wholly solved by either surgical or legal manoeuvres”."Trans-sexuality: A Case of the 'Emperor's New clothes'"
Hakeem contributed a paper, "Trans-sexuality: A Case of the 'Emperor's New clothes'", to the anthology from the Portman Clinic, Lectures on Violence, Perversion, and Delinquency. As the title indicates, he compares transsexuality to the story by Hans Christian Andersen about a king who goes naked thinking that he is wearing a special suit because no one will speak the truth.
Hakeem defines a trans-sexual as
"an individual who is biologically and unambiguously a member of one sex who holds the strong belief that he or she is in fact a member of the opposite sex". Not desires to be, or is striving to be, but is.He takes exception to a 2002 article in the Psychiatric Bulletin where the authors refer to hormonal and surgical treatment as the appropriate treatment for trans-sexuals. Hakeem objects to the presumption that conventional psychotherapy, such as that in fact practised at the Portman Clinic, is not indicated. He objects that to see the core belief defining a trans-sexual as '"an encapsulated mono-delusional belief" is "surprisingly controversial":
"the very nature of the delusion being encapsulated means that such individuals are not 'psychotic' in the same way as, for example, a person with active schizophrenia or another disintegrative condition and explains why such individuals are able to function as perfectly able and capable human beings who do not appear to be affected in any other way than their apparent convictions over their gender."And furthermore:
"It seems very hard for psychiatrists to challenge the fundamental core belief of the trans-sexual and examine with them what actually it is to be the opposite sex or indeed, more importantly, what it is to be any sex, without falling into the trap of personally or socially constructed actual or mythical gender stereotypes".He muses that it is "almost as if we were performing neurosurgery by operating on a person's genitalia", and that it is "too politically incorrect even to question the false-belief systems of these individuals".
He mentions some of his patients: C has never had an identity, and if she were to become a man she believes that she could become a 'real' person; A, a retired ex-marine in his 50s, divorced and a father, attempted to become a women in her 30s; F, an immigrant with no friends after 30 years in Britain, thinks that would be less depressed as a woman; B detests homosexuality, and must become a women before having a relationship with a man.
Hakeem then iterates again that “one cannot actually change gender", and bemoans the lack of long-term follow-up studies to support the assumption that surgery is the appropriate treatment (unlike psychotherapy!). He dismisses the explanation that once trans-sexuals have had the operation, they no longer want to be medicalized.
He repeats his opposition to a person being allowed to marry as "a person of the sex which they are not", and his opposition to the changing of birth certificates "which is a record of one's gender at a certain point in time" (though without mentioning the problem of persons being obliged to produce their birth certificates). He concludes with a terrible possibility:
"a man marrying what he presumed to be a woman who had a female passport, a birth certificate declaring him to be female at time of birth, who is taken to be female and an individual whom he believed he could marry and who could be the mother of his children but in reality his wife actually being a man".www.drazhakeem.com
The Transgender/Gender Identity page on his web site and aimed at the general public is far less confrontational:
"If a person is assessed and is clearly seeking physical gender reassignment and has no uncertainty about this then they are referred to the appropriate gender clinic. For other patients who may have more atypical gender presentations such as those described above they may be suitable for a specially tailored psychotherapeutic intervention aimed at further clarifying and establishing an understanding and certainty of their sense of gender which may or may not correlate with their biological sex.".Transgender: Time to Change
In May 2011 the Royal College of Psychiatrists arranged a one-day meeting, "Transgender: Time to Change", featuring papers from Az Hakeem and Julie Bindel, but with no input from any trans persons. Understandably there was an outcry from trans persons, and the meeting was cancelled.
*Not the US footballer.
- R. Berkowitz, S. Dermen, D. Gamble, A. Hakeem, C. Minne & J. Woods. "Transsexuals Need Therapy Not Surgery". Letter to The Daily Telegraph, 15 July 2002.
- Az Hakeem. "Trans-sexuality: A Case of the 'Emperor's New clothes'". In David Morgan and Stan Ruszczynski. Lectures on Violence, Perversion, and Delinquency. London: Karnac, 2007.
- Natasha Kennedy. "Cis people telling trans people how they should feel, be, think, act". In High Heels, 18 March 2011. http://natachakennedy.tumblr.com/post/3938401415/cis-people-telling-trans-people-how-they-should-feel.
I think that for most of my readers there is no need for detailed comments. Az Hakeem makes the case against himself in the above quotations.
- I will point out that he is very coy about himself, hiding not only his age, the year of his graduations, his sexual orientation.
- His understanding of the difference between sex and gender wobbles several times.
- I think that most of us will take objection to a discussion of transsexuality being included in a volume labelled Violence, Perversion, and Delinquency.
- Hakeem quotes the opinions and practices of other Portman Clinicians, but never those of outsiders.
- He and the Portman clinic people assume that transsexuality is a ‘perversion’ – hardly a a starting point for dialogue.
- Likewise the frequent use of delusion, fantasy, false-belief.
- Hakeem mentions that he has several patients who are homophobic like B, but there is no mention of therapy to cure their homophobia.
- He admits that most transsexuals are sane by any other measure, but when he discusses his patients, they all seem to have other problems.
- He really does not seem to understand that most transsexuals, not regarding themselves as sick, obviously do not continue with a psychiatrist after getting the approval letter.