In 1952 he applied to enter in the Register of Corrected Entries substitutions of his name and sex. This was granted, based on his oath and medical evidence. A few months later, he married Isabella Mitchell, his housekeeper.
In 1965 his elder brother died, and he was to assume the Baronetcy. His cousin, John Alexander Cumnock Forbes-Semphill, contested the inheritance on the grounds that Ewan was female. A two-year court battle ensued, first in the Scottish Court of Session where Dr Charles Armstrong gave evidence that Ewan was intersex, and then the case went to the Home Secretary (the future Prime Minister), James Callaghan. A letter from Ewan’s sister was produced to the effect that he was female, but Ewan’s wife testified that they had normal intercourse. The Session judge decided that Ewan was “predominately male”, though intersexed. The Right Honourable James Callaghan, after consulting with the Lord Advocate, directed that Sir Ewan Forbes (he had dropped the ‘Semphill’) should be entered in the Roll of Baronets as The 11th Baronet of Craigievar and The 20th Lord Semphill, Sir Ewan Forbes of Craigievar,
John Forbes-Semphill finally became the 21st Lord Semphill when Ewan died.
No public records of either the Court of Session or of the Lord Advocate's advice are available. This would appear to be an aristocratic privilege, but resulted in the precedent not being considered in April Ashley’s divorce (Corbett vs Corbett) in 1970.
- Z. J. Playdon. “The Case of Ewan Forbes”. Press for Change. June 1996. Archive.
- Kay Brown. “Dr. Ewan Forbes-Semphill’. Transsexual, Transgender, and Intersex History. www.transhistory.net/history/TH_ForbesSemphill.html. 1998. Archive.
- Tom Peterkin. “Sex-change baronet's estate is sold for £1m”. The Daily Telegraph 10/11/2003. www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2003/12/01/nest01.xml.